[{"NUM":6,"bookMap":{"种次F":"","标准编码":"978-7-5197-2185-5","可外借数":4,"上月外借册数":0,"去年外借册数":0,"封面":"","采编审核":0,"分类字符数据":"","全文服务器ID":0,"操作员":95,"索书号2":"","种次数据":234,"内容介绍1":"","语种":"CHI","本月外借册数":0,"排架号":"","库键码":1,"ILAS记录号":0,"出版日期":"2018","已外借数":2,"COVERPATH":"http://img1.doubanio.com/view/subject/s/public/s29793080.jpg","题名2":"合同法总论","采编审核员":"","分类号":"","出版地":"北京","索书号":"D923.61/H23=4","价格":128,"索书号5":"","索书号6":"","种次字母":"H","索书号3":"","责任者一":"","索书号4":"","索书号9":"","翻阅次数":0,"主键码":1436039,"索书号7":"","索书号8":"","SUMMARYS":"比较法与解释论（代四版前言） 2015年8月，哈佛大学校园里游人如织。匆匆穿行校园，见黑槐树的花落了一地，让人想到此时北京的清华园，景象应该相似，既不是人间四月天，也不是五月槐花香。由于是假期，在哈佛大学法学院兰德尔（Christopher Columbus Langdell, 1826-1906）法学图书馆四楼阅览室里，看书的人并不多。室内墙壁上挂着许多哈佛法学名家的画像，我所坐书桌旁的画像正好是威利斯顿（Samuel Williston, 1861-1963），而我却拿着一本柯宾（Arthur Linton Corbin, 1874-1967）的《柯宾论合同》第四卷，翻开精装封面，赫然映入一个人的签名：Lon L. Fuller（富勒，1902-1978）。无疑，几十年前，这本书属于签名者所有，签名者也一定熟读过这本书。富勒曾是哈佛法学院教授，虽已去世，其合同法教科书却在不断地出新版。方斯沃斯（E. Allan Farnsworth, 1928-2005）也已去世，只是不知他的书是否有人接续修订。这些人的书，都在这层阅览室的书架上，可随手取来阅读。机缘巧合，让我这位中国人来到这个阅览室里，阅读这些非汉字写成的图书。法及法学，均属地方性知识；美利坚这片土地上的法，对于中国人而言，只算是外国法或者比较法（作为比较对象的“法”）。这样的比较法，对于我们，究竟有什么意义？ 在“三版前言”中，我曾写道：“《合同法》是比较法的产物，是典型的‘混合继受’的结果。立法者的任务固已完成，留给司法者及学者的任务却异常繁重。解释论的展开必然是以‘整合解释’为归趋，这也就意味着‘法典继受’后，我们无法通过简单的‘学说继受’来代替中国学者对《合同法》的解释论作业，我们无法通过翻译外国的教科书来代替中国的教科书。中国法官及学者，任重而道远。”这段文字，今天依然是我的心声。 法律比较（Rechtsvergleichung）或者比较法之目的或功能通常体现于获取新知，通过比较观察，提升对于相关法秩序的理解，或者借以填补其法律漏洞。而通过比较探寻发现某领域法秩序的共同基础，为追求统一法奠定基础，则被视为是法律比较的一项新任务（eine neue Aufgabe）。 仅就前者而言，了解你的邻居，是为了更好地了解自己。阅读比较法，让人获得不同的启发或者灵感，这一点在人世间是共通的。当我阅读威利斯顿先生在1899年发表在《哈佛法律评论》上的关于大陆法系双务合同债的牵连性及履行抗辩权的论文时，读到的是他对于比较法的重视及运用（尽管那时“比较法”观念尚在孕育过程中），并深为其研究能力（包括阅读拉丁文、法文、德文的能力）及洞察力所折服，深信其作为合同法大家，绝非浪得虚名。这种比较法传统，在霍姆斯（Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr., 1841-1935）、柯宾、卢埃林（Karl Llewellyn, 1893-1962）、方斯沃斯等人身上，均有体现。20世纪美国合同法领域，群星璀璨，比较法功不可没。面对这闪耀的群星及其巨著，我所能表达的只有敬意！ 21世纪的美国，是否还需要像威利斯顿、柯宾及方斯沃斯这样的合同法Principle Writer以及谁会成为这一传统的继任者？对此，我们还需要进一步观察。不过，钟摆似乎摆向另一个方向，如今的美国法学学人似乎不太在意比较法，而更在意“法和经济学”（Law and Economics）。经济分析的势头强劲，业已攻占了所有主流的美国法学院。从老波斯纳（Richard Posner, 1939-）在HeinOnline数据库中被引次数，也可有所反映，这老先生两万多次的被引，恐怕在今天的美国，鲜有法学教授能出其右。2015年夏天从哈佛大学法学院荣休的肯尼迪（Duncan Kennedy, 1942-）先生，这位批判法学运动（The Critical Legal Studies Movement）的旗手，在与我谈及美国法学院的现状时，“批判法学”的本色依旧：“现在的美国人以为什么都是他们发明的，他们不再去阅读欧洲的文字和思想。”我去拜访肯尼迪先生，第一次在其研究室见面时，他讲的第一句话竟是“我也是合同法学者”。我丝毫不怀疑合同法在其心目中的重要位置，因为在他研究室的一幅表现1976其年成为哈佛大学法学院教授时形象的油画像上，那个意气风发的年轻学者手中拿着一本大部头的著作——《肯尼迪论合同》，那一定是他那时的一个梦想。40年后，肯尼迪先生终究没有出版一部真正的Treatise叫作《肯尼迪论合同》，个中原因，不曾细问。 与美国适成对照的是欧洲或者德国。2017年我重访汉堡马普所，老友中田邦博教授到研究室叫我，同去参加研究所里举行的报告会。报告人H. Rsler教授报告的内容是欧洲法院（European Court of J","今年外借册数":0,"编目审核员":"","调配时间":"","索书号A":"D923.61/H23=4","责任者三":"","责任者二":"","分类":"","编目审核":0,"预约数":0,"编目审核日期":"","封面地址":"","内容介绍":"","责任者四":"","文献类型":0,"图象页数":0,"责任者":"韩世远著","版次":"第4版","下载":0,"种次字符数据":"","分类数据":923.61,"出版者2":"法律出版社","MARC类型":"","封面服务器ID":0,"首馆键码":1,"索书号15":"","采编审核日期":"","索书号14":"","索书号13":"","索书号12":"","索书号11":"","责任者2":"韩世远著","索书号10":"","全文地址":"","题名":"合同法总论","翻译题名":"","处理日期":1693487593000,"分类字母":"D","题名缩写":"","丛书名":"","册数":4,"索书号16":"","累计外借册数":32,"调配员":"","修改人员":410,"出版者":"法律出版社","创建时间":"","卷标":"","种次":"","下载服务器ID":0,"下载地址":""},"ID":"e7bb0520f0b1aeb08a775f8c5c03d6b6"},{"NUM":6,"bookMap":{"种次F":"","标准编码":"978-7-300-27075-3","可外借数":4,"上月外借册数":0,"去年外借册数":0,"封面":"","采编审核":0,"分类字符数据":"","全文服务器ID":0,"操作员":95,"索书号2":"","种次数据":242,"内容介绍1":"","语种":"CHI","本月外借册数":0,"排架号":"","库键码":1,"ILAS记录号":0,"出版日期":"2019","已外借数":1,"COVERPATH":"","题名2":"合同法案例研习","采编审核员":"","分类号":"","出版地":"北京","索书号":"D923.65/W24-2","价格":68,"索书号5":"","索书号6":"","种次字母":"W","索书号3":"","责任者一":"","索书号4":"","索书号9":"","翻阅次数":0,"主键码":1490511,"索书号7":"","索书号8":"","SUMMARYS":"","今年外借册数":0,"编目审核员":"","调配时间":"","索书号A":"D923.65/W24-2","责任者三":"","责任者二":"","分类":"","编目审核":0,"预约数":0,"编目审核日期":"","封面地址":"","内容介绍":"","责任者四":"","文献类型":0,"图象页数":0,"责任者":"王利明著","版次":"","下载":0,"种次字符数据":"","分类数据":923.65,"出版者2":"中国人民大学出版社","MARC类型":"","封面服务器ID":0,"首馆键码":1,"索书号15":"","采编审核日期":"","索书号14":"","索书号13":"","索书号12":"","索书号11":"","责任者2":"王利明著","索书号10":"","全文地址":"","题名":"合同法案例研习","翻译题名":"","处理日期":1693402074000,"分类字母":"D","题名缩写":"","丛书名":"","册数":4,"索书号16":"","累计外借册数":22,"调配员":"","修改人员":410,"出版者":"中国人民大学出版社","创建时间":"","卷标":"","种次":"","下载服务器ID":0,"下载地址":""},"ID":"0889e7b72c70beaed4c815031b5feedb"},{"NUM":6,"bookMap":{"种次F":"","标准编码":"978-7-301-33511-6","可外借数":1,"上月外借册数":0,"去年外借册数":0,"封面":"","采编审核":0,"分类字符数据":"","全文服务器ID":0,"操作员":113,"索书号2":"","种次数据":91,"内容介绍1":"","语种":"CHI","本月外借册数":0,"排架号":"","库键码":1,"ILAS记录号":0,"出版日期":"2022.10","已外借数":0,"COVERPATH":"","题名2":"中国刑法论","采编审核员":"","分类号":"","出版地":"北京","索书号":"D924.01/G91","价格":88,"索书号5":"","索书号6":"","种次字母":"G","索书号3":"","责任者一":"","索书号4":"","索书号9":"","翻阅次数":0,"主键码":2064369,"索书号7":"","索书号8":"","SUMMARYS":"","今年外借册数":0,"编目审核员":"","调配时间":"","索书号A":"D924.01/G91","责任者三":"","责任者二":"","分类":"","编目审核":0,"预约数":0,"编目审核日期":"","封面地址":"","内容介绍":"","责任者四":"","文献类型":0,"图象页数":0,"责任者":"郭自力主编","版次":"第7版","下载":0,"种次字符数据":"","分类数据":924.01,"出版者2":"北京大学出版社","MARC类型":"","封面服务器ID":0,"首馆键码":1,"索书号15":"","采编审核日期":"","索书号14":"","索书号13":"","索书号12":"","索书号11":"","责任者2":"郭自力主编","索书号10":"","全文地址":"","题名":"中国刑法论","翻译题名":"","处理日期":1679917190000,"分类字母":"D","题名缩写":"","丛书名":"","册数":1,"索书号16":"","累计外借册数":5,"调配员":"","修改人员":412,"出版者":"北京大学出版社","创建时间":"","卷标":"","种次":"","下载服务器ID":0,"下载地址":""},"ID":"ada62d0c41879c4eb4e0ea5c0964ee03"},{"NUM":4,"bookMap":{"种次F":"","标准编码":"978-7-302-60389-4","可外借数":2,"上月外借册数":0,"去年外借册数":0,"封面":"","采编审核":0,"分类字符数据":"","全文服务器ID":0,"操作员":52,"索书号2":"","种次数据":83,"内容介绍1":"","语种":"CHI","本月外借册数":0,"排架号":"","库键码":1,"ILAS记录号":0,"出版日期":"2022","已外借数":0,"COVERPATH":"","题名2":"GO语言编程从入门到实践","采编审核员":"","分类号":"","出版地":"北京","索书号":"TP312.8GO/H83","价格":108,"索书号5":"","索书号6":"","种次字母":"H","索书号3":"","责任者一":"","索书号4":"","索书号9":"","翻阅次数":0,"主键码":1993532,"索书号7":"","索书号8":"","SUMMARYS":"","今年外借册数":0,"编目审核员":"","调配时间":"","索书号A":"TP312.8GO/H83","责任者三":"","责任者二":"","分类":"","编目审核":0,"预约数":0,"编目审核日期":"","封面地址":"","内容介绍":"","责任者四":"","文献类型":0,"图象页数":0,"责任者":"黄永祥著","版次":"","下载":0,"种次字符数据":"","分类数据":312.8,"出版者2":"清华大学出版社","MARC类型":"","封面服务器ID":0,"首馆键码":1,"索书号15":"","采编审核日期":"","索书号14":"","索书号13":"","索书号12":"","索书号11":"","责任者2":"黄永祥著","索书号10":"","全文地址":"","题名":"GO语言编程从入门到实践","翻译题名":"","处理日期":1675306656000,"分类字母":"TP","题名缩写":"","丛书名":"","册数":2,"索书号16":"","累计外借册数":2,"调配员":"","修改人员":412,"出版者":"清华大学出版社","创建时间":"","卷标":"","种次":"","下载服务器ID":0,"下载地址":""},"ID":"1cde1e83689e1da1c1116e6bd86e0b95"},{"NUM":3,"bookMap":{"种次F":"","标准编码":"978-7-115-57320-9","可外借数":1,"上月外借册数":0,"去年外借册数":0,"封面":"","采编审核":0,"分类字符数据":"","全文服务器ID":0,"操作员":113,"索书号2":"","种次数据":13,"内容介绍1":"","语种":"CHI","本月外借册数":0,"排架号":"","库键码":1,"ILAS记录号":0,"出版日期":"2021","已外借数":0,"COVERPATH":"","题名2":"HTML5与CSS3基础教程","采编审核员":"","分类号":"","出版地":"北京","索书号":"TP312.8HT/K13","价格":109.8,"索书号5":"","索书号6":"","种次字母":"K","索书号3":"","责任者一":"","索书号4":"","索书号9":"","翻阅次数":0,"主键码":2035319,"索书号7":"","索书号8":"","SUMMARYS":"","今年外借册数":0,"编目审核员":"","调配时间":"","索书号A":"TP312.8HT/K13","责任者三":"","责任者二":"","分类":"","编目审核":0,"预约数":0,"编目审核日期":"","封面地址":"","内容介绍":"","责任者四":"","文献类型":0,"图象页数":0,"责任者":"(美) 乔·卡萨博纳著","版次":"第2版","下载":0,"种次字符数据":"","分类数据":312.8,"出版者2":"人民邮电出版社","MARC类型":"","封面服务器ID":0,"首馆键码":1,"索书号15":"","采编审核日期":"","索书号14":"","索书号13":"","索书号12":"","索书号11":"","责任者2":"(美) 乔·卡萨博纳著","索书号10":"","全文地址":"","题名":"HTML5与CSS3基础教程","翻译题名":"","处理日期":1675322551000,"分类字母":"TP","题名缩写":"","丛书名":"","册数":1,"索书号16":"","累计外借册数":1,"调配员":"","修改人员":412,"出版者":"人民邮电出版社","创建时间":"","卷标":"","种次":"","下载服务器ID":0,"下载地址":""},"ID":"13b7d3626ac57268f55bb230e6baef7e"},{"NUM":3,"bookMap":{"种次F":"","标准编码":"978-7-5693-2414-3","可外借数":2,"上月外借册数":0,"去年外借册数":0,"封面":"","采编审核":0,"分类字符数据":"","全文服务器ID":0,"操作员":113,"索书号2":"","种次数据":24,"内容介绍1":"","语种":"CHI","本月外借册数":1,"排架号":"","库键码":1,"ILAS记录号":0,"出版日期":"2022","已外借数":1,"COVERPATH":"","题名2":"极简R语言入门","采编审核员":"","分类号":"","出版地":"西安","索书号":"TP312.8PY/W24","价格":69,"索书号5":"","索书号6":"","种次字母":"W","索书号3":"","责任者一":"","索书号4":"","索书号9":"","翻阅次数":0,"主键码":2035808,"索书号7":"","索书号8":"","SUMMARYS":"","今年外借册数":1,"编目审核员":"","调配时间":"","索书号A":"TP312.8PY/W24","责任者三":"","责任者二":"","分类":"","编目审核":0,"预约数":0,"编目审核日期":"","封面地址":"","内容介绍":"","责任者四":"","文献类型":0,"图象页数":0,"责任者":"王亮, 洪明月编著","版次":"","下载":0,"种次字符数据":"","分类数据":312.8,"出版者2":"西安交通大学出版社","MARC类型":"","封面服务器ID":0,"首馆键码":1,"索书号15":"","采编审核日期":"","索书号14":"","索书号13":"","索书号12":"","索书号11":"","责任者2":"王亮, 洪明月编著","索书号10":"","全文地址":"","题名":"极简R语言入门","翻译题名":"","处理日期":1675322603000,"分类字母":"TP","题名缩写":"","丛书名":"","册数":2,"索书号16":"","累计外借册数":5,"调配员":"","修改人员":412,"出版者":"西安交通大学出版社","创建时间":"","卷标":"","种次":"","下载服务器ID":0,"下载地址":""},"ID":"12581b427f01912efa7b6cdbdb4b8307"},{"NUM":3,"bookMap":{"种次F":"","标准编码":"978-7-115-60020-2","可外借数":2,"上月外借册数":0,"去年外借册数":0,"封面":"","采编审核":0,"分类字符数据":"","全文服务器ID":0,"操作员":113,"索书号2":"","种次数据":502,"内容介绍1":"","语种":"CHI","本月外借册数":0,"排架号":"","库键码":1,"ILAS记录号":0,"出版日期":"2023.01","已外借数":0,"COVERPATH":"","题名2":"Python Web开发项目教程:Flask版","采编审核员":"","分类号":"","出版地":"北京","索书号":"TP312PY/H50-2","价格":49.8,"索书号5":"","索书号6":"","种次字母":"H","索书号3":"","责任者一":"","索书号4":"","索书号9":"","翻阅次数":0,"主键码":2065084,"索书号7":"","索书号8":"","SUMMARYS":"","今年外借册数":0,"编目审核员":"","调配时间":"","索书号A":"TP312PY/H50-2","责任者三":"","责任者二":"","分类":"","编目审核":0,"预约数":0,"编目审核日期":"","封面地址":"","内容介绍":"","责任者四":"","文献类型":0,"图象页数":0,"责任者":"黑马程序员编著","版次":"","下载":0,"种次字符数据":"","分类数据":312,"出版者2":"人民邮电出版社","MARC类型":"","封面服务器ID":0,"首馆键码":1,"索书号15":"","采编审核日期":"","索书号14":"","索书号13":"","索书号12":"","索书号11":"","责任者2":"黑马程序员编著","索书号10":"","全文地址":"","题名":"PYTHON WEB开发项目教程FLASK版","翻译题名":"","处理日期":1679922545000,"分类字母":"TP","题名缩写":"","丛书名":"","册数":2,"索书号16":"","累计外借册数":1,"调配员":"","修改人员":412,"出版者":"人民邮电出版社","创建时间":"","卷标":"","种次":"","下载服务器ID":0,"下载地址":""},"ID":"718b871cb32cd8587b4e4f47904f8a41"},{"NUM":3,"bookMap":{"种次F":"","标准编码":"978-7-100-12683-0","可外借数":2,"上月外借册数":0,"去年外借册数":0,"封面":"","采编审核":0,"分类字符数据":"","全文服务器ID":0,"操作员":52,"索书号2":"","种次数据":"","内容介绍1":"","语种":"chi","本月外借册数":0,"排架号":"","库键码":1,"ILAS记录号":0,"出版日期":"2017","已外借数":0,"COVERPATH":"","题名2":"哲学大纲","采编审核员":"","分类号":"","出版地":"北京","索书号":"B561.54/L07-20","价格":45,"索书号5":"","索书号6":"","种次字母":"","索书号3":"","责任者一":"","索书号4":"","索书号9":"","翻阅次数":0,"主键码":1348335,"索书号7":"","索书号8":"","SUMMARYS":"","今年外借册数":0,"编目审核员":"","调配时间":"","索书号A":"B561.54/L07-20","责任者三":"","责任者二":"","分类":"","编目审核":0,"预约数":0,"编目审核日期":"","封面地址":"","内容介绍":"","责任者四":"","文献类型":0,"图象页数":0,"责任者":"(英) 伯特兰·罗素著 BERTRAND RUSSELL","版次":"","下载":0,"种次字符数据":"","分类数据":"","出版者2":"商务印书馆","MARC类型":"","封面服务器ID":0,"首馆键码":1,"索书号15":"","采编审核日期":"","索书号14":"","索书号13":"","索书号12":"","索书号11":"","责任者2":"(英) 伯特兰·罗素著 Bertrand Russell","索书号10":"","全文地址":"","题名":"哲学大纲","翻译题名":"","处理日期":1506325532000,"分类字母":"","题名缩写":"","丛书名":"","册数":2,"索书号16":"","累计外借册数":5,"调配员":"","修改人员":38,"出版者":"商务印书馆","创建时间":"","卷标":"","种次":"","下载服务器ID":0,"下载地址":""},"ID":"b51916202ba95f4aa5ff1d286c84f05f"},{"NUM":3,"bookMap":{"种次F":"","标准编码":"978-7-115-48465-9","可外借数":2,"上月外借册数":0,"去年外借册数":0,"封面":"","采编审核":0,"分类字符数据":"","全文服务器ID":0,"操作员":95,"索书号2":"","种次数据":"","内容介绍1":"","语种":"chi","本月外借册数":0,"排架号":"","库键码":1,"ILAS记录号":0,"出版日期":"2018","已外借数":0,"COVERPATH":"","题名2":"Python网络爬虫实例教程:视频讲解版","采编审核员":"","分类号":"","出版地":"北京","索书号":"TP311.561/Q20","价格":49.8,"索书号5":"","索书号6":"","种次字母":"","索书号3":"","责任者一":"","索书号4":"","索书号9":"","翻阅次数":0,"主键码":1442863,"索书号7":"","索书号8":"","SUMMARYS":"","今年外借册数":0,"编目审核员":"","调配时间":"","索书号A":"TP311.561/Q20","责任者三":"","责任者二":"","分类":"","编目审核":0,"预约数":0,"编目审核日期":"","封面地址":"","内容介绍":"","责任者四":"","文献类型":0,"图象页数":0,"责任者":"齐文光编著","版次":"","下载":0,"种次字符数据":"","分类数据":"","出版者2":"人民邮电出版社","MARC类型":"","封面服务器ID":0,"首馆键码":1,"索书号15":"","采编审核日期":"","索书号14":"","索书号13":"","索书号12":"","索书号11":"","责任者2":"齐文光编著","索书号10":"","全文地址":"","题名":"PYTHON网络爬虫实例教程视频讲解版","翻译题名":"","处理日期":1542163634000,"分类字母":"","题名缩写":"","丛书名":"","册数":2,"索书号16":"","累计外借册数":20,"调配员":"","修改人员":393,"出版者":"人民邮电出版社","创建时间":"","卷标":"","种次":"","下载服务器ID":0,"下载地址":""},"ID":"e255aeaa05618d2e5e2b0fd0290ede15"},{"NUM":3,"bookMap":{"种次F":"","标准编码":"978-7-5702-2787-7","可外借数":1,"上月外借册数":0,"去年外借册数":0,"封面":"","采编审核":0,"分类字符数据":"247.5","全文服务器ID":0,"操作员":113,"索书号2":"","种次数据":38.62,"内容介绍1":"","语种":"CHI","本月外借册数":0,"排架号":"","库键码":1,"ILAS记录号":0,"出版日期":"2023","已外借数":0,"COVERPATH":"","题名2":"高山下的花环","采编审核员":"","分类号":"","出版地":"武汉","索书号":"I247.5/L38.6=2","价格":32,"索书号5":"","索书号6":"","种次字母":"L","索书号3":"","责任者一":"","索书号4":"","索书号9":"","翻阅次数":0,"主键码":2179939,"索书号7":"","索书号8":"","SUMMARYS":"","今年外借册数":0,"编目审核员":"","调配时间":"","索书号A":"I247.5/L38.6=2","责任者三":"","责任者二":"","分类":"","编目审核":0,"预约数":0,"编目审核日期":"","封面地址":"","内容介绍":"","责任者四":"","文献类型":0,"图象页数":0,"责任者":"李存葆著","版次":"","下载":0,"种次字符数据":"38.6=2","分类数据":247.5,"出版者2":"长江文艺出版社","MARC类型":"","封面服务器ID":0,"首馆键码":1,"索书号15":"","采编审核日期":"","索书号14":"","索书号13":"","索书号12":"","索书号11":"","责任者2":"李存葆著","索书号10":"","全文地址":"","题名":"高山下的花环","翻译题名":"","处理日期":1713525266000,"分类字母":"I","题名缩写":"","丛书名":"","册数":1,"索书号16":"","累计外借册数":2,"调配员":"","修改人员":394,"出版者":"长江文艺出版社","创建时间":"","卷标":"","种次":"","下载服务器ID":0,"下载地址":""},"ID":"697fd22228d7350a5925eeefdba7eb0e"}]